The Doctors' Dilemma

Publication: Melbourne Herald
Date: 06 October 1922

During Health Week various doctors have prescribed various delectable kinds of food and drink, declaring them injurious. Sugar, white bread, and other foods have been loudly denounced.

Why do all the things I crave
Happen not to be my grave?
All the things I love and long for?
While what I'd not give a song for—
Things I loathe and things I hate—
Help me to a healthful state!

Why should doctors be unkind,
saying that to feed my mind?
I must feed my body ever
On some slush, and 'ere endeavour,
By consuming tons of tripe,
To attain the age called "ripe"?

Doctor Jones says gnawing bones
Builds the body up, and tones:
All the system, while cold water,
Wards off divers - like or oughter
While a meal of melon pie
Will promote longtev-ity.

Doctor Mann says fancy "sweets"
Is not half as good as bran;
It brings on - he says neuralga
shingles and appendicitis
While a good square feed of chaff
Helps you give all this the laugh

Doctor Ladd says bran is bad
And who eat such stuff are mad
Peanuts are the true health givers
Building long striving healthy livers,
And the man who dines on chaff
May compose his epithaph

When I bath I like it hot,
Doctor Watt explains what rot
If you would have health and power
Take each morn a tepid shower
Doctor White says rubbish
sponge.
Doctor Wright says not cold 
plunge.