Publication: Melbourne Herald
Date: 10 July 1922
The New York Sun comments on Mr. H Barville's suggestions for the experiment of coloured labor in Northern Australia, where it would most certainly make Australia essentially a failed state as an appendage not of Europe but of Asia.
An old man who had once been Premier of a White State in a White Australia sat in his study and pondered over old days. He gazed through the window at the gaudy Chinese shops over the way, where bare-footed coolies passed and passed with their burdens. An occasional white man walked languidly up the street, but no white woman was to be seen. The few that remained were indoors, for there was danger in the streets for unguarded white women. ‘Yet,’ mused the old Premier, ‘this country is rich — very rich. No white man works with his hands. He is the master, and the labor of the nation is done by the lower races. I have done good work.’ He rang the bell, and his Japanese servant appeared. ‘Tell the woman who cleans these rooms—’ he began. ‘The black woman,’ said the servant, ‘was taken from the house this morning suffering with leprosy. That is why your room has not been cleaned, sir.’ The old man sighed. ‘But there are others,’ he said. ‘Mostly Indians,’ answered the Japanese, ‘and none of them are room- cleaners. A matter of caste, you know.’ The old man sighed again. ‘We must be patient,’ he said. ‘These people have made the country prosperous. Now, please tell the cook—’ ‘The Chinese cook,’ replied the servant, ‘is off today. He had gone to a meeting of his secret society. They are considering a new movement, and have adopted a new slogan. It is: “Australia for the Asiatics.” Many other races are joining the society, for success is promised. I am think- ing of joining myself.’ ‘You!’ cried the old man. ‘You who have been faithful to me — and to the White Race all these years! What is my country coming to? My country that I have always regarded as the Hope of Europe!’ For the first time, a look of insolence crept into the eyes of the servant. ‘The Hope of Europe?’ he said. ‘Master, you have dreamed. We have learned long since that the White Man is a fool, who dreams only of prosperity today, and takes no thought for tomorrow, when his very prosperity may bring him ruin. Yesterday your Australia was the Hope of Europe. Tomorrow it will be the back yard of Asia. Master, the centuries have taught Asia how to wait.’